Tuesday, December 22, 2009

My Review of "Willing to Believe"

As one of Dr. R.C. Sproul's more in-depth studies, Willing to Believe takes the reader through a systematic study of the major positions that have arisen within the Christian church regarding the interaction between God's will and man's will specifically in the salvation process (hence the title). From Pelagius to Lewis Chafer (the founder of Dallas Theological Seminary) Sproul explores the beliefs that have united and divided Calvinists, Arminians, and Dispensationalists scrupulously in nine focused chapters, drawing heavily upon the writings of each individual and group he chooses to focus on. Throughout, he consistently articulates and defends the Reformed monergistic position of Augustine, Luther, Calvin, and Edwards while critiquing the synergism he sees in the ideas of Pelagius, Arminius, Finney, and others.

The strengths of this work are mainly those common to Sproul's writing. His humble, matter-of-fact approach to difficult issues of theology and philosophy make him both understandable and enjoyable. In Willing to Believe Sproul proves himself an able defender of the biblical doctrines of original sin, the grace of God (sola gratia), and regeneration. In addition, he excells at exploring the difference between the violation of the human will and the changing of the human will, and expressing the importance of this distinction. Finally, by appealing directly to the writings of those he studies Sproul paints an adequate and accurate portrait of the views he discusses, and he is faithful to glean meaning from context first without resorting to more commonly used exegetical shortcuts.

Among the few weaknesses worth mentioning, Willing to Believe suffers slightly from its systematic approach. Every chapter is consistently between 16 and 22 pages long, and each seems to have been allotted the exact same amount of space, naturally leading the reader to feel that some views are not given enough study and that others are emphasized too much. This somewhat mechanical feel notwithstanding, Sproul does a good job of developing the theme of encroaching pelagianism (and semi-pelagianism) throughout, and so this imperfection should not cast a shadow on this excellent treatise. All in all, Willing to Believe is truly a worthwhile read for anyone interested in the theology behind free will and soteriology.

Saturday, November 28, 2009

Chapter 3

After introducing the nature of knowledge in chapter 1 and expounding upon the purpose of knowledge in chapter 2, Calvin narrows his focus in chapter 3 to argue that the knowledge of God is "naturally implanted in the human mind". He is so bold as to call this argument "beyond dispute" because "God Himself...has endued all men with some idea of His Godhead, the memory of which He constantly renews and occasionally enlarges, that all to a man...may be condemned by their own conscience when they neither worship Him nor consecrate their lives to His service". Thus, the support for the argument is grounded first and foremost in the nature of God, and not in human reasoning. But because of his audience, Calvin provides human reasons nevertheless:

1) "There is no nation so barbarous, no race so brutish, as not to be imbued with the conviction that there is a God."

2) "There never has been, from the very first, any quarter of the globe, any city, any household even, without religion"

3) "We know how reluctant man is to lower himself, in order to set other creatures above him. Therefore, when he chooses to worship wood and stone rather than be thought to have no God, it is evident how very strong this impression of a deity must be"

This I find to be perhaps the most convincing of Calvin's proofs. Even in America, land of the free, where the individual is emphasized above all else, there are echoes of this principle. For us it is not so much in choosing to subordinate ourselves to worship (though this is still prevalent in a large portion of the globe), but in our constant search for significance or purpose or anything outside of ourselves, regardless of how much we tell ourselves (and each other) "to look within". There is no significance in man alone, nor is it anything other than absurd to worship and bow down to man, and as Calvin so skillfully points out, on some level we all instictually know this to be true.

4) "Even the wicked themselves...are an example of the fact that some idea of God always exists in every human mind."

Calvin is referring here to those "who deny the being of a God", offering Caesar Caligula as an example of one who possessed "audacious contempt of the Deity" and still felt utter dread "when any indication of divine wrath was manifested". His point is that even the most convinced atheist will "whether they will or not...occasionally feel the truth which they are desirous not to know", namely that God exists.

5) "When the stupid hardness of the heart, which the wicked eagerly court as a means of despising God, becomes enfeebled, the sense of deity, which of all things they wished most to be extinguished, is still in vigor, and now and then breaks forth."

This says nothing more than that the sense of God that is "indelibly engraved on the human heart" cannot be erased, but only ignored for a time. Man in the hardness of his heart can suppress this knowledge for a time, but he cannot keep this up for a lifetime.

In conclusion, Calvin lays out the consequences of failing to seek after the knowledge of God, for "if all are born and live for the express purpose of learning to know God, and if the knowledge of God, insofar as it fails to produce this effect, is fleeting and vain, it is clear that all those who do not direct the whole thoughts and actions of their lives to this end fail to fulfill the law of their being." This in the end is what sets mankind apart from the beasts of the field, the knowledge and worship of God, without which we can only be helplessly evil or hopelessly meaningless.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Chapter 2

In the second chapter of the work, Calvin elaborates on "what it is to know God", which he defines as going beyond the mere idea that He exists to the apprehension of "what it is befitting to know concerning Him." In other words, "what it is for our interest, and conducive to His glory". Calvin carefully distinguishes also between the perception of God that no man will have "until Christ interpose to make our peace" (i.e. we are regenerated and saved), and the general knowledge of God's power, benevolence, and worthiness. And it is in expanding upon this subject that he provides us with some very rich insights, a few of which are below:

"it will not...be sufficient simply to hold that [God] is the only being whom all ought to worship and adore, unless we are also persuaded that He is the fountain of all goodness, and that we must seek everything in Him, and in none but Him."

"we must be persuaded not only that as He once formed the world, so He sustains it by His boundless power, governs it by His wisdom, pereserves it by His goodness, in particular, rules the human race with justice and judgment, bears with them in mercy, shields them by His protection; but also that not a particle of light, or wisdom, or justice, or power, or rectitude, or genuine truth, will anywhere be found, which does not flow from Him, and of which he is not the cause"

From here, the argument shifts to the usefulness and importance of such knowledge of God. Calvin skillfully points out that "this sense of the divine perfections is the perfect master to teach us piety". For until we know God, how can we expect to please Him? And on an even more foundational level, until we come to the Truth about God, how can we expect to know Him? And still more foundational, until we know truths about God, how can we expect to come to the Truth about God?

Calvin is certainly in no way arguing that knowledge is the most important attribute a Christian could possess, for it is "piety" (which will be discussed further down) and not knowledge that he puts as the end. Furthermore, the origin and emphasis of all true knowledge can be no other than God Almighty, for "in this way we must learn to expect and ask all things from Him, and thankfully ascribe to Him whatever we receive", and "the effect of our knowledge rather ought to be, first, to teach us reverence and fear; and, secondly, to induce us, under its guidance and teaching, to ask every good thing from Him, and, when it is received, ascribe it to Him." This effectively strips the knowledgeable Christian of any legitimate grounds for pride, for pride cannot co-exist with "piety".

Finally, Calvin describes the "pious mind", giving it the following characteristics:

1) It is "content to have [God] in the character in which He manifests Himself".
2) It leads a man to "[cast] himself entirely upon [God's] faithfulness".
3) It leads a man to "[embrace] Him not less as the avenger of wickedness than as the rewarder of the righteous; because he perceives that it equally appertains to His glory to store up punishment for the one, and eternal life for the other."

Thus, the nature of piety as it relates to knowledge is that it seeks to know God as He is by learning and obtaining true knowledge about Him, which naturally does and should lead to a complete dependence upon Him for everything good, a confident expectation that He is sufficient, and a reverent worship of Him for all of these reasons. If the knowledge of God does not lead to these things, then it is alone, and even the knowledge of God is useless if it is alone.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Chapter 1

“Our wisdom, insofar as it is to be deemed true and solid wisdom, consists almost entirely of two parts: the knowledge of God and of ourselves.”

With these words, John Calvin begins his magnum opus, The Institutes of the Christian Religion. They are quite appropriate I believe, and I do not think that I (and Calvin) are alone in holding such an opinion. At the start of his own great work The Knowledge of the Holy, A.W. Tozer writes that “what comes into our minds when we think about God is the most important thing about us.” A look at the Westminster Shorter Catechism reveals that the answer to the first question asked also agrees with this statement.


Q: What is the chief end of man?
A: Man’s chief end is to glorify God, and to enjoy Him forever.



Thus, the reason we are on earth is to bring glory to God, which requires a knowledge of God sufficient enough to understand how this can be accomplished. “The fear of the LORD is the beginning of wisdom, and the knowledge of the Holy One is understanding” (Proverbs 9:10). And of course, if we are to do anything at all, at least a base knowledge of ourselves is necessary.

That being said, Calvin spends his first chapter discussing in detail how we both arrive at a knowledge of God by looking honestly at our own lives and discovering who we really are (“an immense series of disgraceful properties”), and arrive at a true knowledge of ourselves only by looking at the God who made us in His image (Genesis 1:26-27). By way of example, the author asks us to consider a man looking around on a sunny day. As his eyes take in many sights, the man is pleased with the sharpness of his vision until he comes to the realization that this pales dreadfully in comparison with the powerful sun which provides the light by which he sees. So it is with me, for I am very pleased to go my merry way basking in everything that I am able to do (or keep myself from doing) without a second thought for the God who constantly provides everything from the self-control that I am able to sometimes utilize to the very breath that keeps my body alive.

A far cry from my usual response is that of the ancients, who fell on their faces and prepared for death upon seeing a part of the glory of God (see Isaiah 6). This is the proper way for mankind to relate to God, who is neither the cuddly teddy bear nor the gracious slot machine that we often make Him out to be. And while knowledge on its own is next to worthless, we cannot aspire to be wise (which involves right action) until we know who we are, and more importantly who God is.

Monday, October 13, 2008

The Original 300 (part 2)

When last we left Gideon, he had been summoned to deliver his nation of Israel from the oppression of the Midianites with this commission: "Have I not sent you?" (v. 14), a summons that we as Christians are often called to answer. And what was Gideon's response? "O Lord, how shall I deliver Israel? Behold, my family is the least in Manasseh, and I am the youngest in my father's house" (v. 15, emphasis mine). Rather like myself, Gideon is far too preoccupied with his own perceived shortcomings and lack of qualifications to see the amazing assurance of the promise that God was making to Him. Nevertheless, God in His great patience makes it even more clear: "Surely I will be with you, and you shall defeat Midian as one man." (v. 16). The Lord Almighty is quick to redirect Gideon's focus here. When we are called by God to do something great, our proper response should not be to look at ourselves and at our own shortcomings as Gideon does, but to look at the One who is with us. "If God is for us, who is against us?" (Romans 8:31b). What God is essentially saying to Gideon is: "Look, I have determined to free my chosen people (of whom you are one) from the oppression of the Midianites by the strength of my infinite power, and I have decided to bring you along to accomplish this and to make you a valiant warrior. 'Surely I will be with you, and you shall defeat Mididan as one man.'" God has even revealed directly that Gideon will be victorious. And what is the response here? "If now I have found favor in Your sight, then show me a sign that it is You who speak with me." (v. 17). The fear and doubt is still there and still prevalent, but Gideon is beginning to display the smallest hint of faith. And all it takes is a mustard seed...

Monday, October 6, 2008

The Original 300 (part 1)

As I recently read through the story of Gideon in Judges 6-8, there were several things about this fascinating story that especially stood out to me:

First, the greeting Gideon received from the angel of the LORD: "The LORD is with you, O valiant warrior" (6:12). Now, from all evidence given to us, if there was any description that Gideon was farthest from, valiant warrior would take the cake. Not only did the angel find him threshing wheat in a wine press, cowering from Midianite raiders (6:11), but Gideon named himself in verse 15 "the youngest in [his] father's house", which was "the least in Manasseh", one of the two half-tribes of Israel. Yet God names him valiant warrior. Why? The answer lies in the same greeting. "The LORD is with you." It was certainly not anything that Gideon did on his own that made him a valiant warrior, and though from our finite perspective we might say that God recognized potential in Gideon, yet the source of any such potential would be from none other than the Creator. Rather, it was God who supplied the power.

Let's continue to God's first command to Gideon: "Go in this your strength and deliver Israel from the hand of Midian. Have I not sent you?" Again the key is not with Gideon and whatever strength he had, but with God's call on his life. God had appointed Gideon a task to complete, or a tale "to get landed in" as Samwise Gamgee might say, just as He has given each and every one of His followers a part to play in the great story of life, in which the ultimate goal is His glory and the greatest tool we are given is the faith to trust Him. How many times have we been called to something great with the promise: "Have I not sent you?"