Sunday, July 4, 2010

Right Theology vs. Right Understanding

I recently stumbled across a blog entry written by Donald Miller (author of Blue Like Jazz), which discussed what Miller sees as a growing tendency in western Christianity to create a false god out of proper theology, which can be substituted for an actual relationship with the Living God. During the course of framing his argument, Miller stresses that while right theology is important because it can serve as a guardrail for our knowledge of God, it is not essential for salvation. In fact, his argument allows for a genuine Christian to believe in multiple gods (polytheism). He defends this by asking a very simple, yet poignant question: Have you ever come to see that some area of your theology was wrong after becoming a Christian? As the answer to this question should always be “yes”, it seems that he has a point. In light of this, I would like to add some of my own thoughts on how right theology relates to salvation.

1. Theology encompasses more than just ideas about God

In its purest form, “theology” is simply what it means, the study of God. It is easy (and correct) to claim that having a relationship with God is more important than knowing some correct things about God, but does not the very concept of having a relationship with God count as an idea about Him? Having right theology is much more than having the ability to spout off a list of God’s attributes. An unsaved scribe was able to correctly identify the greatest commandment of God’s Law (see Mark 11:28-34). However, what is that commandment? “Hear, O Israel! The LORD our God is one LORD; and you shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind, and with all your strength” (Mark 11:29-30). The beginning of this commandment is a true idea about God (“The LORD our God is one LORD”), and the commandment then moves on to speak of our relationship with God (“and you shall love the LORD your God…”). I think this order is very significant. We move from true ideas about God to a right relationship with Him.

2. One form of bad theology is not equal to another

This statement is more difficult to justify, because truth is absolute, and so on one level, any false idea is just as much not-true as any other. However, I believe that this is a biblical idea, and to some extent common sense can also help. There are two instances of the apostle Paul calling for another to be anathema (“accursed”). The first is in 1 Corinthians 16:22 (“If anyone does not love the Lord, he is to be accursed.”), and the second is in Galatians 1:8 (“But even if we, or an angel from heaven, should preach to you a gospel contrary to what we have preached to you, he is to be accursed!”). I believe that this shows that Paul treated deviations from the gospel message of Jesus Christ as more serious than deviations from predestination (see Romans 9:14-21 for how he deals with these). Bad theology regarding predestination is just as “not-true” as bad theology regarding the gospel, but the two are not equal. A common sense example: we would not treat a person in the church who denied that God displays just wrath the same way that we would treat a person in the church who believed that God was a caterpillar! An important implication of this is that blanket statements about the importance (or unimportance) of right theology are either unwise or require additional clarification. Note also that one of Paul’s anathemas relates to teaching false ideas (Galatians 1:8), and one is reserved for not having the proper relationship with God (1 Corinthians 16:22). Both are essential.

3. To a certain extent, right theology is necessary to enter into a relationship with God

If we define “right theology” as having a completely true understanding of everything about God (or even as having no false ideas about God), then the only man who could ever claim to have right theology would be Jesus Christ. If this kind of right theology is necessary for salvation, then we are all in royal trouble. However, if we distinguish between the elements of right theology that are necessary for salvation (we will call these elements a “right understanding” of God), and those that are not, we can arrive at the biblical picture. Thus, we could state that while “right theology” is not a requirement for salvation, “right understanding” about God is. What exactly “right understanding” about God entails, I will attempt to address in a future post.