Showing posts with label free will. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free will. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

My Review of "Willing to Believe"

As one of Dr. R.C. Sproul's more in-depth studies, Willing to Believe takes the reader through a systematic study of the major positions that have arisen within the Christian church regarding the interaction between God's will and man's will specifically in the salvation process (hence the title). From Pelagius to Lewis Chafer (the founder of Dallas Theological Seminary) Sproul explores the beliefs that have united and divided Calvinists, Arminians, and Dispensationalists scrupulously in nine focused chapters, drawing heavily upon the writings of each individual and group he chooses to focus on. Throughout, he consistently articulates and defends the Reformed monergistic position of Augustine, Luther, Calvin, and Edwards while critiquing the synergism he sees in the ideas of Pelagius, Arminius, Finney, and others.

The strengths of this work are mainly those common to Sproul's writing. His humble, matter-of-fact approach to difficult issues of theology and philosophy make him both understandable and enjoyable. In Willing to Believe Sproul proves himself an able defender of the biblical doctrines of original sin, the grace of God (sola gratia), and regeneration. In addition, he excells at exploring the difference between the violation of the human will and the changing of the human will, and expressing the importance of this distinction. Finally, by appealing directly to the writings of those he studies Sproul paints an adequate and accurate portrait of the views he discusses, and he is faithful to glean meaning from context first without resorting to more commonly used exegetical shortcuts.

Among the few weaknesses worth mentioning, Willing to Believe suffers slightly from its systematic approach. Every chapter is consistently between 16 and 22 pages long, and each seems to have been allotted the exact same amount of space, naturally leading the reader to feel that some views are not given enough study and that others are emphasized too much. This somewhat mechanical feel notwithstanding, Sproul does a good job of developing the theme of encroaching pelagianism (and semi-pelagianism) throughout, and so this imperfection should not cast a shadow on this excellent treatise. All in all, Willing to Believe is truly a worthwhile read for anyone interested in the theology behind free will and soteriology.